

Ask ten besan producers which mill they'd buy next and you'll probably hear two camps. One swears by the hammer mill: simple, robust, understood by every maintenance fitter in the industrial area. The other has moved to an air classifying mill and talks about tighter fineness and fewer complaints on premium grades. Both camps are usually right about their own plants. They just started with different products and different customers.
So rather than declare a winner, this article lays out how to decide. If you're choosing a besan grinding machine for a new line, or wondering whether your existing gram flour mill machine is holding you back, these are the questions worth working through.
First, how each one controls size
In a hammer mill, rotating hammers break the dal by impact inside a chamber lined with a perforated screen. Particles keep getting hit until they're small enough to pass through the screen holes. The screen sets an upper limit on particle size. Anything smaller than the holes can leave, including a good share of very fine particles that were produced along the way.
An air classifying mill combines a grinding rotor with a built-in classifier wheel. Airflow carries ground particles up to the classifier, which lets particles that have reached the target size leave and sends oversize particles back to be ground again. Because finished particles leave as soon as they're ready, they spend less time being hit, which limits overgrinding and tends to produce a narrower particle size distribution.
That difference, an upper limit versus active selection, is behind almost every trade-off that follows.
Factor 1: How fine, and how tightly specified?
Start with what the buyer actually asks for. Many besan grades for general retail and food service are specified loosely: "fine" or "coarse", passing a given sieve. A well-maintained screen mill handles this kind of specification comfortably, and switching between fine and coarse grades is largely a matter of changing screens.
It gets harder when the specification tightens. Some industrial buyers, premix manufacturers and exporters want a defined band with limits on fines and oversize, not just a pass-through sieve. This is where classification earns its keep, because it controls both ends of the distribution rather than only the top.
Factor 2: Will it stay consistent over a long run?
This is the factor most often missed during purchase and most often discussed after commissioning. In a hammer mill, hammers wear and screen holes enlarge as the run goes on, especially if any grit gets through cleaning. As they wear, the output gradually drifts coarser. Plants manage it with change schedules, but it means the product at the end of a campaign isn't quite the product at the start.
In an air classifying mill, the cut size is set by the classifier and airflow rather than by hole size, so output tends to hold more steadily as grinding parts wear, though wear still affects throughput and needs attention. If your customers notice small shifts in texture between lots, this factor alone can tip the decision.
Factor 3: Heat and the fat in chickpea
Chickpea has more natural fat than most pulses. Grinding generates heat, and heat plus fat makes fine besan prone to stickiness, buildup and lumping. Overgrinding makes it worse, because energy spent turning already-fine particles into even finer ones ends up as heat.
Both mill types need to be run with heat in mind. The point in favour of classification is that releasing particles as soon as they reach size reduces this wasted grinding. Whatever you choose, ask the supplier how temperature rise is managed, and ask to see it measured on your dal.
Factor 4: How many products will this mill make?
A plant that grinds one or two besan grades all year has different needs from one that switches between fine besan, coarse besan, moong flour and a premix base every week. Hammer mills change grade by changing screens, which is simple but adds downtime and handling. Air classifying mills change grade largely through classifier speed and airflow settings, which can make frequent switches quicker, though each new product still needs its settings established through trials.
Cleaning between products matters too. Look at access to the grinding chamber, how completely the mill empties and how long a full clean-down actually takes.
Factor 5: Floor space, auxiliaries and upkeep
An air classifying mill integrates grinding and classification in one unit, which saves the space of a separate mill and classifier. But it works with a larger air system, so the cyclone, filter and fan need to be sized and laid out together with the mill. A hammer mill is mechanically simpler and familiar to most maintenance teams, with predictable wear parts. Think honestly about who will maintain the machine and what spares you can stock.
Bringing it together
Plenty of plants end up with both: a hammer mill for high-volume standard grades and an air classifying mill for fine and premium besan. That's often a sensible answer rather than a compromise.
One last step
Whatever you lean towards, run a grinding trial on your own chana dal at your own target specification. Ask for the measured particle size distribution, the product temperature and the throughput achieved at that specification, not at the machine's maximum rating. Those three numbers will tell you more than any brochure.
Click HERE to subscribe to our FREE Weekly Newsletter